My Body Is My Own Business Essay Analysis Thesis

While both of these essays touch on feminist issues, they certainly have their distinct differences that make for some interesting comparison possibilities!

"My Body is My Own Business" is a very straightforward, traditionally organized, persuasive opinion essay. Mustafa makes a clear, specific point--that she is part of a group of Muslim woman who are "reclaiming the hijab, reinterpreting it in light of its original purpose to give back to women ultimate control of their own...

While both of these essays touch on feminist issues, they certainly have their distinct differences that make for some interesting comparison possibilities!

"My Body is My Own Business" is a very straightforward, traditionally organized, persuasive opinion essay. Mustafa makes a clear, specific point--that she is part of a group of Muslim woman who are "reclaiming the hijab, reinterpreting it in light of its original purpose to give back to women ultimate control of their own bodies." She then supports this claim with specific points, including the assertion that the wearing of a hijab prevents the objectification and self-objectification of women based on physical appearance. Her discussion is tight and focused, and is built around this primary argument. She invokes a call to action for women everywhere to abandon the slavery to physical beautification that is created by society's impossible standards: "Narrow hips? Great. Narrow hips? Too bad." There is also a linked theme of cultural tolerance/education in Mustafa's essay, particularly when she alludes to the assumptions about her based on her Middle Eastern dress and appearance.

"The Female Body" by Atwood is an altogether different type of writing. It drops any type of cultural focus, and broadens to span a full spectrum of feminist issues.This is a common topic for Atwood, an extremely well known Canadian author. According to the eNotes author profile on Atwood, "Two concerns remained foremost in her work: the self-realization of women and the cultural independence of Canada." Atwood's style of writing is far different from Mustafa's. It is fragmented (each of those numbered sections has a different focus, and a different story behind it). Also, rather than a first person narrative--with, perhaps, the exception of the first vignette--Atwood"s writing is fictional and contains implied messages. She doesn't have the logical, precise argument that Mustafa does, but uses story to reveal truth. For example, the fourth vignette addresses the difficulty of deciding which approach will foster positive body image in a child, speaks to the danger of media messages, and also celebrates the power of young women to define their own standards of beauty. This type of veiled, loosely implied, non-traditional, fragmented but powerful message is very typical of Atwood's style. See her essay "Happy Endings" for another example.

Touch on differences in both style and scope, and you'll have a successful comparison!

Stereotype ("My Body Is My Own Business" Naheed Mustafa)

Stereotypes are the defining and labeling a specific group of people. All of us have a range of images of people, places, or things which are unique to our personal outlook, but these are of interest our mentalities which appear in our instant. Impacts of stereotyping in our multicultural groups are serious; it will mislead our ability of judgment. In "My Body Is My Own Business" Naheed Mustafa discusses her reasons of wearing the "Hijab", although she is not required to wear one, she does so anyway to strengthen herself. Stereotyping is a method to labeling people, but it will confuse us and we will unable to observe the truth of people in characteristics, ability and personality.

The characteristics with the race and religion of a person will not picture their identity. All Asian look and think alike, all Catholics care for the religion more than their country and all Germans are Nazis and war makers. We always analysis people and attach the result with stereotypes from cultural aspect rather than from our own experience with the groups. "I often wonder whether people see me as a radical, fundamental Muslin terrorist packing an Ak-47 assault rifle inside my jean jacket." (Mustafa, 508) As we can see, culture and religion are major cause of stereotypes. Identify others outlook and dressing, consideration with the idea of terriosts and cold blooded with life sacrifice will appear. We're educated to be smart and clever in this multicultural society, but we can't stop the stereotyping because we are living in it.

Everyone is born will equal strength, the diversity of our abilities will be determine by our effort. Stereotyping is a natural function of a human which we often use to value one another. The term...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

A Theater of My Own Essay

979 words - 4 pages A Theater of My Own   My grandmother, Annie was a seanchai, an Irish storyteller. She was the only great actor I have known intimately. Her stage was the kitchen of her cottage in the West of Ireland and her stories were about her friends and neighbors. She recreated their trials and triumphs and with her talent for mimicry accorded each a speaking part. Her one woman show held me spellbound. She commanded my tears and fits of...

Abortion, and my own thoughts Essay

851 words - 3 pages What would it be like to die so young and so fragile? What would it be like to kill something so young and so fragile? Abortion, in my definition, is the taking of a life. Now it is hard for me to sit here and type this paper when I know good and well that if my daughter or wife were ever raped I would want whatever was inside of them out -- immediately. I think that to take the life of an unborn just because the couple involved were too lazy...

My Business Goals

641 words - 3 pages My Business Goals My business goals or to someday own my own company or become the head of a successful one. I’m currently working at UPS where I am going to soon become a supervisor. I think with my skills of being able to motivate people and work well in a group that it will be a good challenge for me. I’m hoping that with the experience I learn that I will become successful in what I want to become. I’m also helping my sister in-law with...

My Body Is My Own Business: an essay on North America's idea of female beauty, how it affects women, and how the media contributes.

684 words - 3 pages For women, trying to live up to the standards of beauty in North America can be an extremely dangerous feat and is nowhere near an accurate depiction of a female's true beauty. By examining the norm of women's beauty in today's society, the dangers involved in achieving it and how false these standards actually are, one will understand just how unorthodox North American perfection has become. Perfection is a dangerous word that has...

My Teacher is my Muse

1435 words - 6 pages So I took the class because there was nothing else offered that semester that seemed even remotely interesting. My choices were slim. I mean it was Advanced Latin for Geeks, Bowling for Advanced Dorks, or this: The Creative Self. Even though I had always looked upon poetry as a non-serious art, a flaky girly thing to do, I had done my fair share of writing, mostly put into teenage angst ridden song lyrics, but still, how different could this...

Marx’s Views on Religion vs. My Own

551 words - 2 pages Marx’s Views on Religion vs. My Own Karl Marx wrote that religion was, “an opiate of the people.” Although those words were not published in The German Ideology, they best describe his various views on religion. Marx wrote that there was a social relationship between the upper class or bourgeoisie and religion. The upper class that owned the means of production used religion as a tool to keep the working class or proletariat, oppressed and...

My Organisational Experience in The Body Shop

3243 words - 13 pages BA (HONS) Business Studies (2008-2011) SECOND YEAR

My First Venture into Business

796 words - 3 pages Two years ago, my family passed a small farm while driving through the rural hills of Teipe, not far from Beijing. Enticed by a small handmade sign, we stopped to buy strawberries. As we were leaving, a little girl of nine or ten dashed towards me. “Jiejie (sister)" she gasped. "Would you like to buy this straw hat? It’s only three Yuan (US$0.40).” Looking at the hand-made straw hats and bags on the shoulders of this tiny girl, I was...

My Journey Towards Marketing Business

878 words - 4 pages History: I lived in a family which lived their lives working for no one; owning their own business. My father had a wholesale business in which he worked between countries. When I was 18 years old, my mother and I owned a childcare business in my country. After five years I married and moved to USA. Seven years ago, my husband and I bought a convenience store called United Market in Sacramento. We went into partnership with my...

Hockey is My Life

894 words - 4 pages Hockey. A sport I have always loved ever since I was a kid. It was when my dad had taken me to an open ice skate when my hockey life began. I had my first pair of skates as a present when I was four years old. I never really knew of the sport at the time, but now I was able to expirence it. No one was present on the ice as I entered the rink. The cold of the ice ran down my back as I took my first steps on. The cold didn’t stop me though. ...

My Future is Now

559 words - 2 pages My Future is Now   I feel the lush red carpet underneath my elegant heels and smile as cameras rush up to snap pictures of the slow procession.  I slowly walk into the large hall of my very first Hollywood premiere.  A colleague of mine sweeps over with a large grin on her face.               "Bet you thought you'd never be at one of these!" she says...

0 comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *